Montauk Manor

This is a decent place with interesting history. Plenty of parking and the grounds looked beautiful, but everything was closed due to the weather. The interior is a little outdated, but I didn’t mind. I did expect a larger lobby based on the photos, but maybe that was just my perception. Everything is exceptionally clean. The apartment was large, kitchen had all the essentials, and everything worked well. Check in and check out were easy and quick, and all the staff were very friendly and courteous. It was great to have the shuttle at our disposal for anything we wanted, since we came by train. On a more negative side, location of our room was not the greatest. Maybe that was on me, I should have probably asked for a quieter location, as we were right next to the elevator and could hear everything. Also, whoever was staying next door had what I assume was their living room right next to our bedroom. The walls are thin. The guest talked on the phone for literally HOURS, we could hear EVERYTHING, and there was nothing we could do until 11 pm. They kept waking us and our daughter and it was really frustrating because we escaped the city to have peace. Obviously, it’s not the property’s fault that someone was inconsiderate and rude. The staff reacted accordingly as soon as they could. However, the whole experience was sullied and I couldn’t wait to escape. The highlight of the stay was the restaurant and its sweet staff, who went out of their way for our daughter’s birthday.

Things weren’t quite open due to the time of year we went but still it was a safe, clean and good place to stay.

We really love the Manor. It is quiet and the rooms are well kept. The pool was closed which we were not informed about until we arrived. And the free coffee is gone. $11.00 for 2 cups of coffee!

Celebrated our son's 16th birthday...beautiful manor with great dining options. Rooms were beautifully decorated and clean; staff was friendly and open to conversation. Already planning our next trip.

Truly a wonderful stay with easy access to Montauk. Very nice and quiet in the off season to enjoy some local shopping or hiking at one of the parks or the beach. Fantastic indoor restaurant serving delicious Italian and great cocktails at the bar. Simple and convenient express checkout. Looking forward to returning!

This was a great winter getaway in a historic building. It has an old fashioned charm. Friendly staff. Monte's is a very good restaurant. Our room was clean and comfortable. We look forward to our next visit

We absolutely loved the cute apartment styled rooms, we loved the grounds, and shuttle they provided

We always wanted to see Montauk's State Parks. This hotel is located near them. The rooms were lovely and unique. Everyone was so friendly. The restaurant on premises, Monte's, was great too.

Everything staff ,guests location, room lobby. Next time i need try dinning there. Will definitely recommend and return