"Private beach pass is a bonus! Nice pool and room was ok. AC didn’t work well. 5 min drive to beach."

"The hotel felt and looked more like a $50-a-night roadside motel than a beach-side property charging the $600 per night that we paid. The towels were tiny, rough, and so thin that they were see through and we were given no extra pool/beach towels despite the room having a shelf with a written label dedicated to that. We didn’t end up using the pool or beach anyway because both were tiny, overcrowded, and beyond unappealing.  You have to drag your luggage alone up flights of stairs as there is no elevator and no help. Our sheets had a stain upon arrival, the carpet was dirty, and despite staying multiple nights, our room was never serviced. There was no iron, no coffee or water in the room, the refrigerator wasn’t cold and was falling apart, and there wasn’t even a phone to call downstairs. When we requested an iron we were told they didn’t even have any but that a steamer would be sent up- it wasn’t and we had to go downstairs and ask again an hour and a half later. We were also told we’d received the last two clean towels in the hotel… and there wasn’t even water available in the lobby when we checked out. Our friend’s room was even worse, smelling and feeling damp with the carpet turning your feet black if you walked barefoot."

"My partner and I stayed at this property three times last summer, and each visit was a great experience. We paid the pet fee, brought our dogs, always cleaned up after ourselves, kept noise to a minimum, and were usually in bed by 10:00 p.m. The staff was friendly during those visits, and on one occasion they even allowed us to extend our stay, which we really appreciated. Unfortunately, our experience today (July 3,2026) was completely different. We called to book a one-night stay for July 5, and the employee initially told us a room was available. However, as soon as my boyfriend gave his first and last name, she said there was a note on the account stating we were blocked from booking due to a previous issue. When we asked what the issue was, she refused to explain and hung up. We called back several times because we genuinely wanted to understand what had happened and, if we had done something wrong, we were willing to take responsibility. Instead, we were treated rudely and were repeatedly denied any explanation. When my boyfriend asked to speak with a manager or owner, Debbie got on the phone and immediately began yelling. She falsely accused us of being disrespectful to management years ago and claimed we had numerous people coming and going from our room and parking lot. None of this is true. My partner and I were simply looking for a quiet getaway with our dogs, just as we had during our previous stays. There were also other guests staying around us during our visits, so it's possible they are confusing us with someone else. We know our own behavior during our stays, and the accusations they made simply do not match our experience or how we conducted ourselves. They also insisted they knew who we were and even assumed we were from Connecticut, despite us explaining that we are from Massachusetts. Every time we tried to clarify the situation, we were told that all we wanted to do was argue, when in reality we were only asking why we had been blocked and why these accusations were being made. The most disappointing part was that no one was willing to listen to our side. We were judged, profiled, and falsely accused without being given a fair opportunity to respond. At one point, they even said they would review the cameras because they believed we were lying about the date we were trying to book, then placed us on hold and hung up again. I'm not going to beg to stay somewhere that treats potential guests this way. It's incredibly disappointing to go from having several positive experiences to being spoken to with disrespect and accused of things we did not do. Based on how we were treated and the lack of professionalism, I cannot recommend this property to anybody."

"We stayed at Margin Street Inn for one night in May to attend a dinner event nearby and even though it was just one night we absolutely loved our stay and would go back in a heartbeat. The room (Room 10) was beautifully decorated, the whole property is beautiful and the daily breakfast was great. What really sets the inn above and beyond is the warm and hospitable environment that Sarah and Chris have created - we enjoyed getting to chat with Sarah who is incredibly kind. We were already talking about coming back and staying for longer before we even checked out."

"Tranquil, quiet, and a great place to stay if you want a nice getaway. The grounds, rooms, pool, etc. are all well-kept. Free beverages are available by the poolside for all the guests. The Innkeepers, John and Heather, are always there to assist you with whatever you may need. Heather makes a wonderful breakfast each morning. It’s our second straight year going to this place and we’ll definitely return for sure. Thank you John and Heather for making our stay enjoyable and relaxing. See you next year. Pat and Mylene"

"This place is so rundown and old and we could not stay here for our wedding anniversary. I was so upset when we pulled up. It looked like something out of a horror movie! No air conditioning in the dining area. The room air conditioning barely worked. Paint chips all over the entrance. Windows blown out. Disgusting and I can’t believe the cost!"